The second issue of Midnight Screaming Magazine was published April 2009. The cover art, titled "Long Nap" was designed by Jeff Crouch.
- When I First Learned of the Holocaust by Douglass Allen Rhodes
- Cryptic Choices by Anne E Barringer
- Among the Dead by Howie Good
- Activation Tone by Natalie JE Potts
- Engorged by John Greiner
- Keeping the Rhythm by T. Joseph Dunham
- Closeness by April Michelle Bratten